Introduction
1. Management, leadership and organisation in preparing learners for learning
2. Arrangements for preparing learners prior to entering college programmes
3. Arrangements for preparing learners on entry to college programmes
This material may be copied without further permission by education authorities and education institutions in Scotland for use in self-evaluation and planning.
The report may be produced in part, except for commercial purposes, or in connection with a prospectus or advertisement, provided that the source and date therefore are stated.
In colleges we don’t always know the skills or abilities of our learners until they arrive, yet we have only a set amount of time to try and get them from where they are to where they aspire to be. We therefore need to help them prepare for learning in order to enable them to achieve their potential.1
Learners undertake college programmes for a wide range of reasons. For most, it offers a new opportunity or second chance to gain a formal qualification that will help them to access employment, obtain promotion or undertake further studies. For a considerable number of older learners, the learning and teaching environment in colleges is significantly different from their previous encounters with formal learning. Many learners have had a negative experience of previous formal learning situations and as a result are under-confident about their skills and abilities. This was explored in the HMIE Inspectorate of Education (HMIE) report Overcoming Barriers; Enabling Learners (October 2006). It is therefore important that the learning process does not reinforce any previous negative experiences, but rather removes as many barriers as possible. To achieve this, colleges need to assist people to overcome challenges and anxieties which may constrain their confidence and ability to take part in learning situations. By providing people with experiences which help them approach learning more positively and by equipping them with new skills that enable them to engage more fully, colleges play an important role in helping learners maximise their potential.
The project, Preparing Learners for Learning, formed part of the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council’s (SFC) quality enhancement agenda. It focused on exploring the arrangements made by Scotland’s colleges to prepare learners for learning, prior to and at the start of their programme. As a result of this work, HMIE developed key principles derived from the findings of the fieldwork in the form of a toolkit and sent it out to all colleges in November of 2005. The toolkit was designed to assist colleges to evaluate their services and activities in addition to, or along with, existing self-evaluation processes. Since then, many colleges have reported they have found the toolkit useful in:
In response to this feedback, HMIE has updated the toolkit and incorporated links to the SFC/HMIE Quality Framework for Scottish FE Colleges (2004). Many of the aspects of the four capacities identified in Curriculum for Excellence (CfE) are integrated within the key prompts and staff may wish to identify and chart where their activities contribute to this agenda.
The toolkit can be used in different ways. For example, it could be used:
to look at provision for specific groups of learners such as:
across specific levels or modes of learning such as:
at macro and micro levels including:
A specific example would be using the toolkit in conjunction with community learning and development (CLD) colleagues in the planning and monitoring of transition from informal learning to college programmes.
The lists of key prompts, key staff who could be involved, and links to the SFC/HMIE Quality Framework are not exhaustive or prescriptive and represent suggestions to help shape discussion and self-evaluation and quality enhancement activities.
HMIE hopes that colleges will find the toolkit helpful and looks forward to hearing about ways you have used it to help shape and enhance services which benefit learners.
The key principles for effective practice fall into three main sections, as follows:
1. Management, leadership and organisation in preparing learners for learning
1.1 Managers understand the needs of their learners prior to and at the start of their programmes. They use this knowledge to develop and provide services which help learners to prepare for and sustain their learning, and communicate an ethos of assisting learners across the college.
1.2 All teaching and support staff work together effectively to identify issues and develop systems and procedures to enhance the early experience of learners. They have a collegiate approach to helping learners maintain and succeed in their programme of learning.
1.3 College staff monitor and analyse early indicators of learner attendance, retention, achievement and attainment across programme areas and make good use of this information to make amendments and/or provide planned interventions.
1.4 Staff development programmes inform and update teaching and support staff on measures and approaches to support learners prior to and at the start of their programmes. Staff make good use of this information to identify and provide effective support and referral.
1.5 College arrangements for the management and coordination of pre-entry and induction processes are clear and understood by staff.
2. Arrangements for preparing learners prior to entering college programmes
2.1 Arrangements for potential learners to access information on programmes and support services are clear, effective and well understood by staff and learners across all relevant college departments.
2.2 Admission and selection arrangements take good account of the previous experience of learners, their existing skills and individual needs. Staff provide good opportunity for learners to discuss these needs prior to entry and arrange effective support and referral when required.
2.3 Staff proactively and systematically assess preparatory learning requirements. Core, literacy and vocational skills are assessed and gaps identified. Methods of profiling existing skills are learner friendly and appropriate to needs, and encourage learner interaction and participation.
2.4 Staff provide effective and accessible preparatory programmes which assist learners to gain appropriate skills prior to progressing onto mainstream programmes. These programmes take good account of the variety of learner needs and are effective in easing transition to mainstream programmes.
2.5 Staff actively encourage learners to plan their learning, and engage learners in discussion about their curricular programme and options prior to entry. They take good account of learner aspirations and expectations when assisting them to plan their programme.
3. Arrangements for preparing learners on entry to college programmes
3.1 The content of induction programmes is well planned and well paced. It provides an appropriate level of challenge and takes good account of what learners need to know and when they need to know it. Staff take good account of specific programme requirements and the development of transferable skills, and incorporate them into induction activities.
3.2 Guidance arrangements provide effective support for learners at the early stages of their programme. Guidance tutors are accessible and responsive and engage regularly with learners to discuss progress and any issues arising. They actively involve learners in their own learning.
3.3 Staff engage learners in exploring and discussing their specific learning styles and response to different learning approaches. They encourage learners to use this information to identify strategies to maximise their potential and develop learning skills.
3.4 Staff encourage learners to take responsibility for their own learning through assisting them to identify individual goals, plan their learning and reflect on their progress.
3.5 College support and teaching departments monitor closely the early progress and ‘settling in’ of learners. Staff make good use of this information to identify any emerging areas of concern and provide appropriate intervention.
3.6 Access to additional support and resources (including learning support, assistive technologies and alternative formats) is readily available to learners at commencement of their programme and as needs are identified.
3.7 A range of support schemes actively encourage and support under-confident and fragile learners.
1 Quote from Overcoming Barriers; Enabling Learners report, SFC/HMIE, October 2006
|
Key principles |
Key prompts |
Strengths |
Areas for development |
Links to the SFC/HMIE Quality Framework for Scottish Colleges |
1.1 |
Managers understand the needs of their learners prior to and at the start of their programmes. They use this knowledge to develop and provide services which help learners to prepare for and sustain their learning, and communicate an ethos of assisting learners across the college. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
Staff of external partners, for example, schools, CLD providers, employers |
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.1 Educational aims, objectives and targets B1.2 Leadership for learning B1.3 Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B1.4 Achievement of educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B6 Quality assurance B6.1 Policies and procedures |
||
1.2 |
All teaching and support staff work together effectively to identify issues and develop systems and procedures to enhance the early experience of learners. They have a collegiate approach to helping learners maintain and succeed in their programme of learning. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
Staff of external partners, for example, schools, CLD providers, employers |
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.2 Leadership for learning B1.3 Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B6 Quality assurance B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality B7 Quality improvement B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement |
||
1.3 |
College staff monitor and analyse early indicators of learner attendance, retention, achievement and attainment across programme areas and make good use of this information to make amendments and/or provide planned intervention. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
Staff of external partners, for example, schools, CLD providers, employers |
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.4 Achievement of educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support development B6 Quality assurance B6.1 Policies and procedures B7 Quality improvement B7.1 Quality culture B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement |
||
1.4 |
Staff development programmes inform and update teaching and support staff on measures and approaches to support learners prior to and at the start of their programmes. Staff make good use of this information to identify and provide effective support and referral. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
|
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.3 Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B5 Staff B5.1 Staffing B5.2 Staff development and career review process B5.3 Continuing professional development |
||
1.5 |
College arrangements for the management and coordination of pre-entry and induction processes are clear and understood by staff. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
|
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.2 Leadership for learning. Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B5 Staff B5.1 Staffing B6 Quality assurance B6.1 Arrangements for assuring quality |
|
Key principles |
Key prompts |
Strengths |
Areas for development |
Links to the SFC/HMIE Quality Framework for Scottish Colleges |
2.1 |
Arrangements for potential learners to access information on programmes and support services are clear, effective and well understood by staff and learners across all relevant college departments. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
Staff of external partners, for example, schools, CLD providers, employers |
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.2 Leadership for learning B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B5 Staff B5.1 Staffing B6 Quality assurance B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality |
||
2.2 |
Admission and selection arrangements take good account of the previous experience of learners, their existing skills and individual needs. Staff provide good opportunity for learners to discuss these needs prior to entry and arrange effective support and referral when required. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
Staff of external partners, for example, schools, CLD providers, employers |
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.3 Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B6 Quality assurance B6.1 Policies and procedures B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality |
||
2.3 |
Staff proactively and systematically assess preparatory learning requirements. Core, literacy and vocational skills are assessed and gaps identified. Methods of profiling existing skills are learner friendly and appropriate to needs, and encourage learner interaction and participation. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
Staff of external partners, for example, schools, CLD providers, employers |
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process The teaching process Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.1 Educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion A2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion A2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B6 Quality assurance B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality B7 Quality improvement B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement |
||
2.4 |
Staff provide effective and accessible preparatory programmes which assist learners to gain appropriate skills prior to progressing onto mainstream programmes. These programmes take good account of the variety of learner needs and are effective in easing transition to mainstream programmes. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
Staff of external partners, for example, schools, CLD providers, employers |
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.3 Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B6 Quality assurance B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality B7 Quality improvement B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement |
||
2.5 |
Staff actively encourage learners to plan their learning, and engage learners in discussion about their curricular programme and options prior to entry. They take good account of learner aspirations and expectations when assisting them to plan their programme. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
Staff of external partners, for example, schools, CLD providers, employers |
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B6 Quality assurance B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality B7 Quality improvement B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement |
|
Key principles |
Key prompts |
Strengths |
Areas for development |
Links to the SFC/HMIE Quality Framework for Scottish Colleges |
3.1 |
The content of induction programmes is well planned and well paced. It provides an appropriate level of challenge and takes good account of what learners need to know and when they need to know it. Staff take good account of specific programme requirements and the development of transferable skills, and incorporate them into induction activities. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
|
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.2 Leadership for learning B1.4 Achievement of educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B6 Quality assurance B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality B7 Quality improvement B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement |
||
3.2 |
Guidance arrangements provide effective support for learners at the early stages of their programme. Guidance tutors are accessible and responsive and engage regularly with learners to discuss progress and any issues arising. They actively involve learners in their own learning. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
|
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.3 Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B5 Staff B5.1 Staffing B5.3 Continuing professional development B6 Quality assurance B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality B7 Quality improvement B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement |
||
3.3 |
Staff engage learners in exploring and discussing their specific learning styles and response to different learning approaches. They encourage learners to use this information to identify strategies to maximise their potential and develop learning skills. Activities relating to learning styles |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
|
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.3 Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B6 Quality assurance B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality B7 Quality improvement B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement |
||
3.4 |
Staff encourage learners to take responsibility for their own learning through assisting them to identify individual goals, plan their learning and reflect on their progress. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
|
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.3 Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B6 Quality assurance B6.1 Policies and procedures B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality B7 Quality improvement B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement |
||
3.5 |
Links to the SFC/HMIE Quality Framework for Scottish CollegesCollege support and teaching departments monitor closely the early progress and ‘settling in’ of learners. Staff make good use of this information to identify any emerging areas of concern and provide appropriate intervention. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
|
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B1 Educational leadership, direction and management A1.3 Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B6 Quality assurance B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality B7 Quality improvement B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement B7.3 Evidence of improvement |
||
3.6 |
Access to additional support and resources (including learning support, assistive technologies and alternative formats) is readily available to learners at commencement of their programme and as needs are identified. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
Staff of external partners, for example, schools, CLD providers, employers |
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.3 Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B5 Staff B5.1 Staffing B5.3 Continuing professional development B6 Quality assurance B6.1 Policies and procedures B6.2 Arrangements for assuring quality B7 Quality improvement B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement |
||
3.7 |
A range of support schemes actively encourage and support under-confident and fragile learners. |
Key staff involved Senior and operational managers and staff responsible for:
Staff of external partners, for example, schools, CLD providers, employers |
A5 Learning and teaching process A5.1 The learning process A5.2 The teaching process A5.3 Context and planning for learning and teaching A7 Learner progress and outcomes A7.1 Learner progress and achievement A7.2 Learner attainment B1 Educational leadership, direction and management B1.2 Leadership for learning B1.3 Implementation of action towards educational aims, objectives and targets B2 Access and inclusion B2.1 Leadership for access and inclusion B2.2 Arrangements for access and inclusion B3 Guidance and support B3.1 Leadership for guidance and support B3.2 Arrangements for guidance and support B4 Resources and services to support the learner B4.3 Centrally available learning materials and equipment B4.4 Facilities to support access and inclusion B6 Quality assurance B6.1 Policies and procedures B7 Quality improvement B7.2 Planning for and managing improvement |