[Previous] [Contents] [Next]

  
Self-evaluation using performance indicators
 
 
 
P.I. 1.2 QUALITY OF COURSES OR PROGRAMMES
 
Theme 1.2.1 Breadth, balance and choice
 
To what extent do courses and programmes provide breadth, balance and choice?
 

How do you know?

Some features you might look for

Does the design of courses or programmes of study take account of equal opportunity?

Is the balance of key elements and skills appropriate for all pupils?

  • Curriculum content promotes access for all pupils, both girls and boys, and prepares them for life in a multiracial, multicultural and multifaith society
  • Problem solving/investigative work forms an integral part of the teaching programme
  • Opportunities are planned to develop team and group work
How well do the courses or programmes take account of national and local guidance?
  • Programmes of study and courses for all pupils are based on national and local guidelines and reflect policies on equal opportunity
  • There is reinforcement of concepts and skills and progressively more demanding tasks which recognise each pupil's ability to succeed
Are courses or programmes in keeping with the school aims relating to equality?
  • Curriculum materials:

    -positively represent sections of society and challenge prejudice and injustice, and racist and sexist views

    -promote personal development and encourage pupils' self-esteem, cultural identity, aspirations and career choice in non-stereotyped ways

    -enable children, young people and adults to understand the roots of discrimination and to challenge it in themselves and others

    -focus on and deal with harassment or denigration and strategies to combat these

  • Courses develop knowledge which is able to be applied in different contexts
Are there appropriate opportunities for pupil choice?
  • There are opportunities for collaborative and independent learning
  • Choice reflects school policies on differentiation, equal opportunities and assessment
  • There is an appropriate range of choices for pupils of all interests and abilities, including partnerships with FE colleges and other schools

Some ways of finding out

Use co-operative teaching with peer evaluation and classroom observation

Management work alongside teachers and pupils; sample pupils' work; observe the outcome of class work

Discuss planning, organisation and management of learning

Ensure self-evaluation takes place through discussion among management, class teachers and learning support staff

Review documentation, course materials and forward plans

 
P.I. 3.1 QUALITY OF THE TEACHING PROCESS
 
Theme 3.1.3 Quality of teacher-pupil dialogue
 
How effective is teacher-pupil dialogue?
 

How do you know?

Some features you might look for

How effectively do teachers interact with the whole class, groups and individuals?
  • A range of teaching styles and learning strategies is used which helps all young people and adults to engage actively in learning
  • Approaches vary to suit the context and the needs of all pupils
  • Teachers are flexible in responding to pupils' academic, personal and social development
How effective are teachers' discussions with pupils in promoting learning and building confidence?
  • Teachers prompt while groups or individuals are working
  • Teachers take account of the needs of bilingual pupils
How successful are teachers at encouraging and valuing pupils' contributions?
  • Teachers make it clear that the achievements and progress of each pupil are valued
  • A variety of responses is used, for example, building on pupils' answers, praise, correcting misunderstandings, encouraging pupils' questions and comments
  • Teachers provide well-considered feedback on pupils' progress
How skilled is teachers' questioning?

How effectively do teachers listen to and use pupils' responses?

  • A range of styles is employed, for example, checking understanding; challenging stereotypes and assumptions; asking for recall, evidence, conclusions, further exploration or explanations; posing problems; using positive examples
  • There is skilled use of a question and answer technique incorporating signing and the use of technology, where appropriate
  • Questions are inclusive of all pupils
  • There is a flexible response to the direction of any discussion
How much care do teachers take to involve all pupils?
  • Talk is used in varied contexts, for example, with classes, groups and individuals
  • Distribution of questions around the class is sensitive to the progress of pupils
  • There are appropriately challenging demands on all pupils in contributing to discussions and answering questions, irrespective of gender, ethnicity or ability
  • All pupils feel able to initiate discussion and ask questions of the teacher
How much effort do teachers put into ascertaining the source of language and learning difficulties so that they can do something about them?
  • Well-timed intervention
  • Efforts to identify the source of difficulties and misunderstandings
  • Willingness to repeat, or provide alternative, explanations

Some ways of finding out

Checklists based on a selection of 'Features to look for'

Discuss video-recordings of teaching activities with other teachers

Arrange mutual observation during team-teaching

Ask pupils to note down the range of opportunities for talk

Discussion with learning support department

Talk to pupils

[Previous] [Contents] [Next]